Home | Contents | Photos | News | Reviews | Store | Forum | ICI | Educators | Fans | Contests | Help | FAQ | Info

Stereotype of the Month Entry

Another Stereotype of the Month entry:

Amador Ledger Dispatch

The little city and the big casino

Friday, August 22, 2003

- Eric Eckerstrom, Fiddletown

Once there was a small city, not a fancy city, but a nice place to live, where people didn't have to lock their doors and could walk down Main Street and say hello to their neighbors. The future looked bright for this city; it was in a beautiful place and people were moving to the area and coming as tourists, spending their money at local businesses.

Then some people came to the city with a plan. They wanted to create a foreign country within the city. They said this country would make the city rich. It could do this because they would start a business there that wasn't allowed in the country of the little city. People would give their money to this business and hope to get more in return -- something for nothing, or a lot for a little.

The foreign country would not have to obey any of the laws of the city or its country, but the new people promised to be nice to the city and give them some of the bundles and piles of money they would make.

The people weren't sure what to do. Their city needed money for their schools and water and sewer. But they also knew of other places that already had the same kind of nation and business within them and none of those places were happy about it.

They were told they couldn't stop the project even if they wanted to, and that if they tried they wouldn't be given anything. So the people thought: "This time it will be different. We can't win anyway, so let's take their money."

Many people came to work to build the new business and much money was spent and the people thought: "This is wonderful." Then finally the business opened. Many came to give the new business their money -- so many that the people of the little city couldn't drive to their work or their own businesses without long waits and some were even hurt by some of those who came and had too much of the drink that the new business sold and gave to them and couldn't drive on the small roads around the city.

Soon the people found that they had to lock their doors and the police had to come to keep bad things from happening because of all the people who came to give money. Some even spent all their time at the new business, thinking that if they gave enough money they'd get a lot more, but they didn't. They lost all they had and some even stole from others to keep trying.

It turned out that the money the city got from the business wasn't enough, and then the city asked for more, the business said: "We're not a part of your country; you can't make us do anything." So the people of the city had to pay out of their own pockets. The local businesses started to fail because no one came to them anymore. People gave their money to the business at the foreign country and the city didn't get any new tax money to pay for all the things the workers in the foreign country needed. Many came; some got paid to count the money, but most didn't get very much to sweep the floors and serve the drinks.

Things were all different. The people couldn't see the stars at night because the new business' neon lights that drew all the cars and gamblers lit up the sky. Instead of farms and beautiful country, the new business with all its money dominated things. Too late, the people realized that they had sold their way of life for a few dollars. Something far more valuable than the promises of the foreign nation and its business partners was lost. If only they had known, they would have fought to save the very things that brought them to their little city in the first place.

It is too late for the people in this fictional story, a fable that has been repeated across this great state. It is not too late for Plymouth and its surrounding area. The casino backers say: "The Ione Band of Miwok Indians is building a casino..." Do you see building going on? They are attempting to build a casino. There are many steps in that process yet to be completed. Approval by the Governor of California and by the Secretary of the Interior must be granted for a group to acquire lands for gaming purposes and the position of surrounding local governments must be taken into account. Your response and the position of the city council are very important.

No one can deny that injustices were committed against California's Native Americans in the past. First by the Spanish, then the Mexican, and then by the United States citizens and governments. Today the power of the vast sums of money, generated by Indian gaming, to influence government officials is creating another kind of injustice. Not only does Indian gambling impact surrounding communities without their consent, but much of the huge profit from Indian gambling goes to shadowy groups of handlers and financial backers.

An exercise of ordinary common sense will show that Plymouth is a completely inappropriate place to transform into a mini Las Vegas. The effects on the little city in the story are all supported by studies, experience and even "Time" magazine.

Where do you stand?

Rob's reply
I stand opposed to stereotypical screeds like this one. Among its gross distortions:

Eckerstrom is obviously projecting his fears in his fable, which he accurately labels a piece of fiction. I suspect he couldn't document any real harm from casinos, so he made up a story instead.

His time would be better spent fighting establishments like Wal-Mart, which actually do destroy mom 'n' pop businesses and suck a community dry. (Those who favor Wal-Marts initially often change their minds.) Casinos aren't the demons he makes them out to be.

Related links
Too-powerful Indians
Greedy Indians
The facts about Indian gaming

* More opinions *
  Join our Native/pop culture blog and comment
  Sign up to receive our FREE newsletter via e-mail
  See the latest Native American stereotypes in the media
  Political and social developments ripped from the headlines

. . .

Home | Contents | Photos | News | Reviews | Store | Forum | ICI | Educators | Fans | Contests | Help | FAQ | Info

All material © copyright its original owners, except where noted.
Original text and pictures © copyright 2007 by Robert Schmidt.

Copyrighted material is posted under the Fair Use provision of the Copyright Act,
which allows copying for nonprofit educational uses including criticism and commentary.

Comments sent to the publisher become the property of Blue Corn Comics
and may be used in other postings without permission.