Columbus Day feteParade organizers held a news conference Monday, at which a Comanche Indian who flew in from Oklahoma told the media that "Columbus was not responsible for the 500 years of history" that followed his sailing from Spain to the Caribbean. Some claim Columbus was responsible for the "genocide" of American Indians that followed.
"The dominant image of this parade is that American Indians are opposed to anything white or European. I don't consider Columbus to be a threat to American Indians. I consider (CU professor) Ward Churchill to be more threatening to American Indians," Yeagley said.Comment:
Yeagley is wasting time on semantics. Columbus didn't knowingly instigate everything that happened in the next 500 years, but he started the ball rolling. In that sense
Columbus is responsible for all the deaths that followed.
This is a standard legal concept, one that even Yeagley should be able to grasp. If you open the door to a criminal and let him commit a crime, you're guilty of aiding and abetting, even if you didn't harm anyone yourself.
But make no mistake about it: Columbus did kill and enslave Indians himself. He's personally guilty of hundreds or thousands of legal or moral crimes.
Obviously Columbus isn't a threat to anyone today, since he's dead. But historical ignorance about him is a threat. Telling Americans that Indians were
uncivilized until he raised them up and enlightened them is a threat.
I hope it's clear
how this is a threat. If not, here's an example:
Right-wing groups want to shut down Indian casinos. Why? Because they question the concept of
tribal sovereignty. Why? Because in their minds, Indians couldn't have had their own governments. Why? Because they were just a bunch of ignornant
savages.
And why do right-wingers think this? Because they learned this version of history in their grade-school classes...and during Columbus Day parades.
Result: Historical ignorance leads to the re-impoverishment of Indians. Without gaming revenues, more Indians suffer from crime, substance abuse, and
suicide.
So beware of Uncle Tomahawk, Americans. Since Yeagley has
argued against tribal sovereignty, he may be a bigger threat to Indians than either Columbus or Churchill.
For more on Yeagley, see
The Anne Coulter of the Native World.